Tags: AMCAS, Case Western Reserve University, Duke, graduate school, GRE, MCAT, medical school, Philips Healthcare, University of Cincinnati, University of Toledo
Anyone that has talked to me in the last year or two knows that I have been on the fence about my future career plans. Doing a co-op at Philips didn’t help my decision as much as I thought it would. I would be equally happy working in a company as an engineer or being a doctor. I had the qualifications for both paths because my undergraduate degree in Biomedical Engineering prepared me for both medical and graduate school.
Many people consider various things when deciding what career path to take. While I would like to make money, I feel that I would be successful enough as an engineer to live comfortably. Doctors make even more so money was not really a deciding factor for me. I’m a hands on individual and frequently try to solve problems so that fits well with an engineering profession, but those traits can also be applied to being a surgeon.
I ended up choosing to give medical school a shot since I had already taken the necessary pre-medical classes, my MCAT was not too bad after taking it a second time, and I felt that my extracurriculars were strong enough to apply. While I would not be a top quartile applicant, I could be fairly competitive in the middle tier of medical schools.
Medical School
With two more interviews (University of Kentucky and University of Toledo) I’m starting to get worried about my chances of getting in. I interviewed at University of Cincinnati early February and just got put on the wait list earlier this week. The entire process has been fairly stressful and there are a lot of places on my application that are kind of weak.
What went wrong
A few things that I would have done differently if I could have done everything over:
- Apply early - I heard some people say to do this but I didn’t realize the gravity of the situation until it was too late. Only after going through the process did I realize how much I jeopardized my chances of even getting a chance to interview by submitting my applications so close to the deadlines. Many people have their primaries in as soon as they can (around July) but I didn’t get those in until around early October. This meant that my secondary submissions were also pushed back until around November and December. Almost all schools will give out more spots earlier in the application cycle. My initial thinking was that since medical school applications are looked at in batches, the earlier people will most likely be the over achieving crowd that will have very exceptional applications. My application would probably be weak in comparison so I would have a better chance applying later with people who would not have as strong of an application. I’m not sure how I led myself to believe that but it was a pretty big mistake.
- I really should have had a lot more clinical experience on my application. I do volunteering but it’s mostly through Alpha Phi Omega so it’s not really very clinical based. Another thing is shadowing - I only shadowed one physician. I shadowed a plastic surgeon for 5 days straight (10 hours a day) which I think is beneficial in that it allowed me to really see what an entire week would be like for a surgeon. The downside is that I only shadowed one surgeon so it could be seen that I don’t have a wide enough scope of the medical field.
- Neither my MCAT nor my GPA was that high. I took the MCAT twice and improved a lot from the first to the second time, but even then my MCAT was only a 33. I’m a huge procrastinator by nature and my plan for MCAT studying was no different. I waited until very late to study and there is just too much material to go over. In order to properly prepare for the MCAT, many people spend several months. I only spent about 3 weeks. My GPA suffered from having a lot of science classes every semester. I never had a semester taking fewer than 17 credit hours and had 3 semesters with 19 or more hours. Not all the schools will give consideration to the difficulty of an engineering curriculum so the GPA probably hurt my chances at a few schools.
- Ask for letters of recommendation earlier. I didn’t start asking for letters of recommendation until early August. Part of this was that I wasn’t sure if I was going to apply for medical school and wanted to wait for my MCAT score before I decided. I had already scored a very high score on the GRE when I took it back in May so I was pretty confident about my chances at grad school. I told myself that if I could get a decent score on the MCAT I would go ahead and give medical school a shot since I had already done much of the work in preparation for medical school. It was pretty stressful waiting for 2 or more months for the people I asked to get their letters of recommendation in. This also created the problem that I procrastinated further since I reasoned that it wouldn’t matter until they got their letter in. This is absolutely not true as you can submit primaries without the letters so I could have done that much sooner.
What went right
Some things that I think I did right:
- I have quite a few extracurricular activities and the important thing is that I was dedicated to a few specific activities and even held leadership positions. My involvement in student government and my role in Kendo club hopefully helped bolster my application.
- Strong research and work experience. I do some sort of research every summer and started as early as my Freshman year. I worked for two summers at the University of Kentucky at the Biomedical Engineering department working on polymers that would be used in orthopedic applications. I spent the summer and fall of my Senior year working at a co-op at Philips Healthcare. I was a verification and validation intern in the CT division but also got some experience working with PET machines. This was a really great experience and one that I thoroughly enjoyed. I learned a lot about how industry works as well as how imaging equipment works.
Backup Plan?
As a backup option I also applied to a few graduate schools for a masters degree in Biomedical Engineering. I applied to University of Pittsburgh, Duke University, and Case Western Reserve University. I just got my acceptance to the program at Duke University which is great news since they’re consistently ranked in the top 5 by US News. I need to give my response by April 15th. I’m not sure whether I will go there if I don’t get into medical school. My fear is that I will become complacent once I start graduate school. There is a high chance that once I start graduate school I will give up on hopes of going to medical school since I would already be at least one year into the graduate program. I also wouldn’t want to waste the money that I spend during that first year of relocation, tuition, etc. so I would most likely just finish my degree and go into industry.
I guess I can’t do much more than try my best at these next two interviews and then see where I am come early April. I won’t hear back from the wait list status of schools until May 15th so I will need to decide on what to do about graduate school before then. It will be a pretty big gamble if I just depend on getting in off of wait lists, but it could be well worth it.

